Skip to the content

Get A Quote

More Than AccountantsMore Than Accountants
  • Who We Help
    • Sole Trader Accounting
    • Small Business Accountants
    • Limited Company Accountants
    • Partnership
    • Limited Liability Partnerships
    • Contractor Accountants
    • Xero Accountants
  • Online Accountancy Services
    • Company Accounts
    • Tax Returns
    • VAT Returns
    • Bookkeeping Services
    • Financial Reports
    • Payroll Services
  • Knowledge
    • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Who We Help
    • Sole Trader Accounting
    • Limited Company Accountants
    • Partnership
    • Limited Liability Partnerships
    • Contractor Accountants
  • Online Accountancy Services
    • Company Accounts
    • Tax Returns
    • VAT Returns
    • Bookkeeping Services
    • Financial Reports
    • Payroll Services
  • Quote Online
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
Categories
Accountancy News

Chocolate Bar Illustrates the Complexities of VAT

  • Post author By Daniel Rose
  • Post date September 15, 2018
  • No Comments on Chocolate Bar Illustrates the Complexities of VAT

There is always something to worry about for businesses when it comes to HMRC. Our tax scheme is so complicated that even the most experienced accountants are prone to having problems. A case in point is a recently settled squabble between HMRC and a company that makes chocolate bars. Who knew a chocolate bar could cause such consternation for the taxman?

The case in question revolves around a company known as Kinnerton Confectionery Ltd. This company, which is classified predominantly as confectionery, produces chocolate bars and other similar products loved by both adults and children alike. They decided to make an allergen-free chocolate bar that people could use for baking purposes. They thought all was well until HMRC came calling.

HMRC claimed that the chocolate bar should be rated as a confectionery rather than zero rated as a baking product. The case went to trial and Kinnerton lost. The government walked away with a £258,470 windfall along with the promise of additional revenues for every bar the company sold.

Want to switch to More Than Accountants? You can get an instant quote online by using the form below. In a like for like comparison for services we are up to 70% cheaper than a high street accountant.

The Government’s Case

Table of Contents

  • The Government’s Case
  • Kinnerton’s Defence
  • Packaging and Intent Are Rating Standards

HMRC maintained that the allergen-free chocolate bar was actually a confectionery rather than a baking product. Their argument rested on a couple of key points.

First, they claimed that Kinnerton did not specifically market the chocolate bar as a baking product. They insisted that if baking was the true purpose of the bar, the company would have held out the product for sale exclusively as such. Instead, they sold it alongside their other confectioneries.

Second, the judge in the case actually looked at Kinnerton’s marketing and noted specific language that was apparently damning. The bar’s marketing advertised it as “ideal for cooking” rather than specifically as a cooking chocolate. This was enough for the judge to declare the bar a confectionery.

Kinnerton’s Defence

Kinnerton defended itself by first explaining the intent of the new bar. They said it was made as an allergen-, nut-, and gluten-free chocolate to be used for baking. They followed up that explanation by pointing out that the wording they used on the product’s packaging was similar to wording used by their competitors to describe similar products. They went so far as to imply that they used competitor products as a model for their own packaging.

Packaging and Intent Are Rating Standards

Kinnerton’s defence was not enough to sway the judge. Apparently, packaging and intent are now rating standards that can be judged in the absence of hard and fast wording. It is not enough that the company produced a product similar to other zero-rated products being sold by their competitors. Instead, it’s more important that the company’s name includes the word ‘confectionery’ and that the chocolate bar was sold alongside its other products.

The point here is not to say that HMRC was wrong or that Kinnerton was right. Tax law is what it is. The point is that this particular case highlights both the ambiguity and complexity of UK tax law. This case comes down to one thing and one thing only: packaging.

If Kinnerton had packaged the chocolate bar differently, so that it was clear to the judge that it was truly a baking product rather than a confection, they probably would have been allowed to continue selling it as a zero-rated product. But because their packaging did not specifically explain that the bar was a baking product, it must be standard rated for VAT purposes.

It makes no sense, yet that’s the way it is. That is why it’s so important for business owners to either be fully competent in tax law or work with accounting professionals who are.

Share this post

By Daniel Rose

Daniel is the co founder of More Than Accountants and an ACCA Chartered Accountant. He will be more than happy to help More Than Accountants clients implement any guides or strategies that he has posted to the blog. If you would like to learn more about becoming a More Than Accountants client you can quote online by using our Unlimited Accountancy Services Quoting Tool.

View Archive →

← The Xero Dashboard: All Your Accounting in One Place → 18 Great Ways to Market a Restaurant without Going Broke

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

By Daniel Rose

Daniel is the co founder of More Than Accountants and an ACCA Chartered Accountant. He will be more than happy to help More Than Accountants clients implement any guides or strategies that he has posted to the blog. If you would like to learn more about becoming a More Than Accountants client you can quote online by using our Unlimited Accountancy Services Quoting Tool.

View Archive →
  • 0161 804 0808
  • Get An Online Quote

EXCELLENT
Based on 214 reviews
Google
Kai W
Kai W
2025-02-12
Excellent accounting service! Very professional and quick at answering my queries. I really enjoy working with them.
Kandice Morris
Kandice Morris
2025-01-30
I cannot recommend More than Accountants highly enough! From the first meeting, I was impressed by their professionalism, knowledge, and dedication to helping clients succeed. They took the time to understand my financial situation and goals, and they provided tailored advice that has significantly impacted my financial health. Their attention to detail is truly commendable. I have always felt confident knowing that my accounts are managed with the utmost precision. Not only did my accountant (Hasrat ) do my taxes promptly, but he also got me a refund!! More than accountants are always available to answer questions and respond quickly, making what could be a stressful process quite manageable. I’m incredibly grateful for their guidance and support, and I look forward to many years of continued collaboration!
Misha Cunningham
Misha Cunningham
2025-01-30
After a bit of a rocky start with this accountants, they now deal with all 4 of my active companies. And, the major contributing factor in this is the excellent care and attention that I receive from Arshiya. I actually insisted that she be kept as my main point of contact in my dealings with More than Accountants and I feel extremely looked after. On another note, their unlimited package is quite expensive, but in my eyes it's worth it as they handle everything, meaning I don't have to worry about anything. Plus, I know if I need anything in the interim it's simply covered in the fees already without needing to fork out extra here and there.
Brian Roache
Brian Roache
2025-01-20
More than accountants have provided an affordable accountancy service to my limited company Reveldrive Limited and dealt with all the formal tax returns and my personal tax. Hasrat has been my contact during the years with them and knows his subject very well.
Henry Dean
Henry Dean
2025-01-13
Wonderful, friendly and talented accountants. They make running my limited company a breeze. I can always rely on them to respond straight away. My accountant Aqsa is a star!
James Brennan
James Brennan
2025-01-13
Waleed, Arshiya and the rest of the team at More Than have been handling our accounts & carrying out payroll duties since March 2024. Since then they have provided the very best service possible, every task they have carried out for the company has been totally faultless and stress free. The attention to detail in assisting the company in the best way possible is highly appreciated and we would recommend them to all companies seeking a professional accountant company
Jade Moon
Jade Moon
2025-01-03
Great accountancy firm. The team are super responsive, nothing is too much trouble and they support small business owners really well.
Cedric PISTOL
Cedric PISTOL
2024-12-31
Very pleased with the support provided by Atif Mahmood & Abdul Moiz, thank you for your patience and your prompt actions!
Stephen Bond
Stephen Bond
2024-12-24
Highly recommended, Waleed is so personal and helpful in all questions asked we started 2 years ago with MTA and together improving year on year.

Company

  • Our Approach
  • Quote Online
  • Contact Us

About the blog

The blog posts are brought to you by More Than Accountants employees and we occasionally allow guest posts that we think could benefit our customer base.

Feel free to contact the poster of the blog for help interpreting or implementing their posts..

Categories

  • Accountancy News
  • Accountancy Software
  • Announcements
  • Business Funding
  • Business Practice
  • Business Tools and Process Automation
  • Company News
  • Customer Relationship Management (CRM)
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Industry News
  • Marketing
  • Uncategorised

Recent Posts

  • Bookkeeping for Beginners: 9 Basic Concepts to Get You Started
  • Bookkeeping Packages Guide
  • What is Double Entry Bookkeeping?
  • Difference Between Accounting and Bookkeeping
  • Xero Training (Talk About How, etc.)

Recent Posts

  • Bookkeeping for Beginners: 9 Basic Concepts to Get You Started
  • Bookkeeping Packages Guide
  • What is Double Entry Bookkeeping?
  • Difference Between Accounting and Bookkeeping
  • Xero Training (Talk About How, etc.)

More Than Accountants is a national online/telephone based accountant.

Head Office
More Than Accountants
Burnden House,
Viking Street, Bolton
Lancashire, BL3 2RR

Telephone:
0161 804 0808

[mnky_list_item icon_fontawesome="fa fa-phone" last_item="last" icon_color="#eeee22"]202-555-0120[/mnky_list_item]
[mnky_list_item icon_fontawesome="fa fa-map-marker" last_item="last" icon_color="#eeee22"]4982 Parkway Street, Los Angeles, CA 90017 [/mnky_list_item]
[mnky_list_item icon_fontawesome="fa fa-clock-o" last_item="last" icon_color="#eeee22"]8AM - 5PM Weekdays[/mnky_list_item]
© 2021 More Than Accountants Limited More Than Accountants is a limited company registered in England under company number 09974015. Our companies house registered office is: More Than Accountants, Burnden House, Viking Street, BL3 2RR. Content is for general information only. Always take advice. FacebookTwitter

Resources

Knowledge Base

How Much Does an Accountant Cost

What is UTR Number and How to Find It

Sole Trader or Limited Company

Bookkeeping Services

Daniel James Tax

Sitemap

Recent Blog Posts

  • Bookkeeping for Beginners: 9 Basic Concepts to Get You Started
  • Bookkeeping Packages Guide
  • What is Double Entry Bookkeeping?

Site

  • Who We Help
    • Sole Traders
    • Limited Companies
    • Partnerships
    • Limited Liability Partnerships
    • Contractors
  • Our Services
    • Company Accounts
    • Tax Returns
    • VAT Returns
    • Bookkeeping Services
    • Payroll Services
  • Contact Us
  • 0161 804 0808
  • info@morethanaccountants.co.uk

Registered office :
Nautica House, Ground Floor,
Waters Meeting Road, Bolton,
Lancashire, BL1 8SW

0161 804 0808
info@morethanaccountants.co.uk

Who We Help

  • Sole Traders
  • Limited Companies
  • Partnerships
  • Limited Liability Partnerships
  • Contractor Accountants
  • Small Business Accountants
  • Xero Accountants
Linkedin Youtube Facebook

Services

  • Company Accounts
  • Tax Returns
  • VAT Returns
  • Bookkeeping Services
  • Financial/Management Reports
  • Payroll Services

Resources

  • Knowledge Base
  • Blog
  • Quoting Tool
  • Accountancy News
  • Accountancy Software
  • Business Funding
  • Business Practice
  • Business Tools and Process Automation
  • Company News
  • Customer Relationship Management CRM
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Industry News
  • Marketing
  • FuturePay Terms And Conditions

Recent Blog Posts

Recent Posts
  • Bookkeeping for Beginners: 9 Basic Concepts to Get You Started
  • Bookkeeping Packages Guide
  • What is Double Entry Bookkeeping?
  • Difference Between Accounting and Bookkeeping
  • Xero Training (Talk About How, etc.)

©  2025 More Than Accountants Limited 

More Than Accountants is a limited company registered in England under company number 09974015.
Content is for general information only. Always take advice.
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
Cookie SettingsAccept All
Manage consent

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
CookieDurationDescription
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional11 monthsThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy11 monthsThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
Functional
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytics
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
Others
Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
SAVE & ACCEPT